Rock Discoveries

Citrine vs Amethyst: Understanding the Differences in Colorful Gems

Gemstones have always been treasured commodities in the world of jewelry due to their rarity, beauty, and symbolic value. Two of these gemstones, Citrine and Amethyst, have gained popularity among collectors and enthusiasts alike.

While they share many similarities in chemical composition and natural occurrence, they possess distinct qualities that set them apart.

This article aims to provide readers with information about Citrine and Amethyst, from their natural formation to their appearance and desirability.

Let’s delve into the world of gemstones and discover what makes these two gems unique.

Desirability of Gemstones

Citrine and Amethyst, along with other precious stones, have been desired and collected by humans for thousands of years. Their profound beauty and rarity make them prized possessions, often used in adornments, ritual and holistic practices, and other special occasions.

Citrine, in particular, has been lauded for its sun-like hue and energy. It was believed to have properties that evoke prosperity, self-confidence, and creativity, making it a favorite among business owners and artists.

Amethyst, on the other hand, is renowned for its deep purple hue, which is believed to evoke a feeling of calmness and spirituality. It has been used in the art of meditation and prayer, as well as in healing practices due to its supposed ability to release negative energy.

Natural Occurrence of Citrine and Amethyst

Citrine and Amethyst are both variety of macrocrystalline quartz. They are formed from silicon dioxide and can be found all over the world, with some places offering more exceptional quality specimens than others.

Citrine crystals are relatively rare in nature and are often found in association with Amethyst. Natural Citrine is typically pale yellow in color, but heat treatment through a specific temperature and duration can create deep yellow or orange hues.

This process improves the gemstone’s transparency, luster, and clarity, increasing its desirability. Amethyst, on the other hand, is most commonly found in geodes, clusters, and crystal points.

These formations are created when quartz containing iron inclusions and other impurities are exposed to high temperatures and pressure and then cooled rapidly. Amethyst can also transform into prasiolite, a green variety of quartz, when exposed to heat and radiation in the earth’s crust for long periods.

Appearance of Amethyst

Amethyst is commonly recognized for its deep saturation of purple coloration. It is a transparent or translucent gemstone that can be found in various shades of purple, from light lilac to dark violet.

The saturation of color is affected by the amount of iron and other impurities present in the crystal during its formation.

The crystal formation of Amethyst is often found in geodes, which are spherical or elliptical hollow rocks that are lined with Amethyst crystals.

Crystal points are also common, which are single spikes of Amethyst that are often used in jewelry. Some Amethyst crystals also undergo color zoning, which produces concentric circles of light and dark coloration that adds to its beauty and uniqueness.

What is Amethyst? Amethyst is a mineral that belongs to the quartz family.

It is created through the combination of silicon dioxide and impurities, such as iron and other minerals. This macrocrystalline quartz is predominantly purple in color, although it can appear in other colors such as white, green, yellow, and brown.

Formation of Amethyst

Amethyst formation is a complex process that requires specific conditions to occur. It begins when a solution containing silicon and oxygen flows into an open space, such as a geode or fissure, where it begins to cool and settle.

Impurities such as iron are also present in the solution, which play an essential role in the crystal’s coloration. As time passes, the temperature and pressure of the solution increase, causing it to recrystallize.

The iron inclusions within the quartz begin to oxidize, giving the crystal its purple hue. The amount of iron present during the crystal’s formation affects the depth of color, with larger inclusions causing darker hues.

Appearance of Citrine

Citrine is a transparent yellow or orange gemstone that belongs to the quartz family. It is formed by the heating of Amethyst or smoky quartz at a specific temperature.

The heat treatment removes elements that cause the crystal to appear purple or gray, leaving behind the characteristic yellow or orange hue.

Citrine has a glass-like luster and is often found in faceted cuts, making it an excellent option for jewelry.

It can often be found in geodes, similar to Amethyst, but is much less common in nature.


In conclusion, the world of gemstones is vast and intricate. Citrine and Amethyst have both been desired and collected for centuries, each possessing unique qualities that make them stand out.

Citrine’s sunny hue and supposed energetic properties evoke feelings of prosperity, self-confidence, and creativity. Amethyst’s deep purple coloration and supposed calming properties make it perfect for meditation, prayer, and healing practices.

Understanding the natural formation and appearance of these gemstones can help us appreciate and value them even more. 3) What is Citrine?

Citrine is a mineral variety of quartz that belongs to the silicon dioxide family of minerals. It is known for its yellow to orange coloration, which is the result of iron in the color centers.

This mineral is widely used in jewelry, and it is often associated with positive energy and abundance.

Formation of Citrine

Citrine is formed from the same chemical compounds as Amethyst and Smoky Quartz, but the differences in the crystal’s formation affect its color. Unlike Amethyst, Citrine undergoes a different process of formation, as it emerges as a yellowish or brownish coloration.

Natural Citrine is relatively rare, and it is formed under specific high-temperature requirements.

Citrine can also be created through the heat treatment of Amethyst.

By applying heat at approximately 470-560C, Amethyst turns into the yellow or orange hue, which is characteristic of Citrine. Heat-treated Citrine is more commonly found, as natural Citrine stones are rare.

Appearance of Citrine

Citrine’s name is derived from the Old French word “citrin,” which means lemon. This name refers to the gemstone’s yellow coloration, which resembles the color of a lemon.

Although this gemstone can range in color from pale yellow to deep orange-brown, the most desirable shades are bright yellow and golden yellow. Citrine is a transparent or translucent gemstone, which means that it can transmit light.

It has a glass-like luster, and it is often found in faceted cuts, which adds to its brilliance. Citrine can also be found as geodes or clusters, similar to Amethyst.

4) Heat Treated Amethyst vs Citrine

Rarity of Natural Citrine

As mentioned earlier, natural Citrine is relatively rare. This rarity is due to the high-temperature requirement for its formation.

Natural Citrine formations are often found in association with Amethyst, and the yellow to orange hue of natural Citrine can be difficult to distinguish from heat-treated Amethyst. This is why natural Citrine is highly prized, and many stones that are sold as Citrine are, in fact, heat-treated Amethyst.

Heat Treatment in Amethyst

Heat treatment is a common practice in the gemstone industry, especially with Amethyst stones. The process involves exposing the gemstone to high temperatures, which causes the stone’s color to change.

In the case of Amethyst, exposing it to heat at a specific temperature (approximately 470-560C) can transform it into Citrine.

When the Amethyst is heated, it loses some of its iron inclusions, which were responsible for its purple coloration and gains more yellow or orange hues.

The heat causes the Fe3+ ion charge to move to a Fe4+ ion charge, and this change of charge is responsible for the color change in the gemstone.

Indicators of Heat Treatment

It can be challenging to distinguish between heat-treated Amethyst and natural Citrine. However, a few indicators can help to identify which gemstone has undergone heat treatment.

Heat-treated gems often have a more solid color than natural Citrine, which can have color zoning. Additionally, the tips of the crystals may look burnt, and the color change in the crystal may not be uniform throughout.

Dichroism is another indicator to identify heat-treated gems. Dichroism refers to the gemstone’s ability to show two colors when viewed from different angles.

Heat-treated Citrine typically has less dichroism than natural Citrine. Many gemologists also use spectroscopy to identify whether a gemstone has undergone heat treatment.


Citrine and Amethyst are two gemstones with unique properties that make them highly valuable to the jewelry industry. Understanding the differences in their formation and the process of heat treatment can help one appreciate the differences between the two gemstones.

Natural Citrine is relatively rare, formed under specific high-temperature conditions. The heat treatment of Amethyst is a process that is widely used to create Citrine, which is more commonly found in the market.

Identifying whether a stone is natural or heat-treated can be challenging but is essential for determining the gemstone’s value. 5)


Gemstones such as Citrine and Amethyst are highly valuable to the jewelry industry. While these gemstones have many similarities in their chemical composition, there are distinguishing qualities that set them apart.

Citrine and Amethyst differ in their natural formation. Citrine requires specific high-temperature conditions during its formation, while Amethyst is created when quartz containing iron inclusions and other impurities are exposed to high temperatures and pressure and then cooled rapidly.

Heat treatment is a process commonly used in the gemstone industry to improve the quality and color of gemstones. Amethyst can be heat-treated to become Citrine, which results in a more common yellow to orange hue.

Natural Citrine, on the other hand, is relatively rare, among the most valuable, and known for its unique and desirable yellow hue. Identifying whether a gemstone is natural or heat-treated is an essential factor that can affect the gemstone’s value.

Natural Citrine often exhibits color zoning or bi-coloration, while heat-treated Citrine has a more solid color. Burnt tips on heat-treated crystals, light color patches, and less dichroism are some other indicators to distinguish natural Citrine from heat-treated gems.

In conclusion, Citrine and Amethyst are both stunning and valuable gems with unique features. Natural Citrine is rare and highly valued in the market, while heat-treated Amethyst is more affordable and widely available.

The key to identifying whether a gemstone is natural or heat-treated often lies in paying attention to its color, physical attributes, and dichroism. Knowing the difference between these gemstones can help collectors and enthusiasts alike appreciate their beauty and value.

In conclusion, Citrine and Amethyst are two beautiful and unique gemstones that are highly valued in the world of jewelry. Understanding the differences in their formation, appearance, and the impact of heat treatment is essential for gemstone enthusiasts.

While natural Citrine is rare and more valuable, heat-treated Amethyst offers a more affordable alternative. By being aware of the indicators of heat treatment, buyers can make informed decisions about their gemstone purchases.

Ultimately, the world of gemstones is vast and fascinating, and Citrine and Amethyst are two examples of the beauty and diversity found within it. FAQs:


What is the difference between Citrine and Amethyst? Citrine is a yellow to orange gemstone formed from high-temperature conditions, while Amethyst is a purple gemstone formed from quartz containing iron inclusions and other impurities.

2. Can Amethyst be turned into Citrine?

Yes, by applying heat at a specific temperature, Amethyst can be transformed into Citrine. 3.

Is natural Citrine expensive? Yes, natural Citrine is rare and highly valued, making it a more expensive option compared to heat-treated Citrine.

4. How can I tell the difference between natural Citrine and heat-treated Citrine?

Natural Citrine often exhibits color zoning, while heat-treated Citrine has a more solid color. Burnt tips on heat-treated crystals, light color patches, and less dichroism are other indicators of heat treatment.

5. Which gemstone is more affordable, Citrine, or Amethyst?

Heat-treated Amethyst is more affordable than natural Citrine.

Popular Posts